Selection & Removal
It is not the job of the candidate to win. The job of the
candidate is to BE the best candidate. Electing the best candidate is the job
of the people. — Jon Roland, to a discouraged campaign worker,
during his campaign for Congress, 1974 |
During the late 20th century the word "liberal" came to mean
someone whose copy of the Bill of Rights was missing the Second and Tenth
Amendments, and the word "conservative" someone whose copy was missing the
First and the Ninth. — Jon Roland, May, 1994 |
Those who cast the votes decide nothing. Those who count the
votes decide everything. — Attributed to Josef Stalin |
| Click on the button to get the indicated file
format: |
| Format |
HTML |
Text |
WP |
PDF |
RTF |
Word |
Image |
| Local |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
| Remote |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
 |
The main methods for selecting officials are:
- Election — By vote, either by the people or some subset
of them.
- Sortition — By lot, the way juries are selected.
- Appointment — Selection by other officials, also called
cooptation, especially when a body appoints its own members.
- Examination — Use of a procedure to rank or reject
contenders, often in conjunction with other methods.
- Rotation — Each of several persons takes turn filling an
office. Usually done under one of the first three.
- Seniority — Usually a method of promotion within a
department or branch.
- Conquest — Surrender to a powerful individual or group,
usually but not necessarily through violence.
- Inheritance — Method characteristic of monarchical or
aristocratic systems.
- Purchase — Usually a corrupt mode of appointment, it
could be made legal.
- Infiltration — Placement by subversive means, or by
influence of a special interest group.
The main methods of removing officials are:
- Expiration of term
- Non-retention
- Termination by superior
- Impeachment and removal
- Resignation
- Death
- Disability
Selection Alternatives and Reform
Approaches to Electoral Reform
Voting Theory and Reform
The Sortition Option —
Articles and links on this method.
Vote rigging
Votescam, by James & Kenneth Collier
— Report of investigation of vote fraud in the United States. Guide for
how to conduct such investigations.
Citizens for Leaders with Ethics & Accountability
Now! (CLEAN) — Investigate vote fraud. Have online photographic
evidence of ballot altering.
Citizens For A Fair Vote Count (CFVC) —
Clearing house for vote fraud investigations.
Voting Integrity Project — Seeks reforms of
the electoral process.
Voteres Unuite! — Seeks fair and accurate counting of votes.
Campaign financing and disclosure
- Enforcement
Federal Election Commission — Administers
reports of campaign funding and disclosure laws and posts data online.
California Fair Political Practices
Commission (FPPC) — Administers 1974 California Political Reform Act
{PRA).
- Resistance
Californians Against Corruption Defense
Fund — Oppose what they claim is corrupt abuse of California PRA.
RealCampaignReform.org — Opposes
legislation to limit campaign contributions and require disclosure of
contributors.
Real Campaign Finance
Reform, by Jon Roland — Article: Mar. 24, 2001
Participation
Ballot Access News — Reports
on the adventures of those trying to get candidates and measures on ballots in
every state.
Electorama — Extensive collection of
documents and links on election reform.
Redistricting
Coalition for Non-partisan Redistricting.
Proposal for redistricting plans in Texas —
Would make use of existing computer programs to draw districts without regard
for ethnicity or voting history.
Redistricting Software — Used to draw district
boundaries. Can be used to make districts that do not take into account voting
patterns of the interests of incumbents.
Fixing the Reapportionment Mess, by
Bill Blomberg, Dec. 7, 2000 — Calls for drawing electoral districts using
impartial computer programs.
- V Demo of Texas
congressional redistricting. Video interview of staff of the Redistricting
Division of the Texas Legislative Council, May 16, 2003, and aired on public
access cable May 17, 2003.
Higher-res
version. You will need the latest version of RealPlayer to view it, and a high-bandwidth
connection to the Internet.
Removal
Impeachment — One of the methods of removal
prescribed by the U.S. Constitution for the president and other high
officials.